The match
Dhuruvangal Pathinaaru
2016India★ 7.8subtitled
A former cop looks back on the case which left him disabled and forced him to quit the force.
Close, not exact
A Simple Plan, but for the guilt that follows the characters
Nothing in the catalog nails this hook as hard as A Simple Plan does, but the films below come honestly close.
If you want a second one
Dark Places
2015France★ 5.9subtitled
A woman who survived the brutal killing of her family as a child is forced to confront the events of that day.